Guide
How to compare supplier quotations fairly: a buyer's checklist
Two quotations for the same RFQ rarely match line for line. This checklist shows what to align before you compare totals.
A quotation is an offer to supply specific goods on specific terms. Comparing totals before the terms are aligned is the usual way to choose the wrong supplier. The steps below turn quotations into like-for-like offers.
Step 1: Align the specification
Put the quotations side by side and check each line against your RFQ.
- Same item, size, rating and standard?
- Same brand, or an equivalent that is documented?
- Same quantity and unit, such as pieces, pairs or boxes?
- Any line missing, or any line substituted without a note?
If the item differs, ask for a datasheet before comparing prices.
Step 2: Check what the price covers
- Is the price per unit or for the lot?
- Packing, loading and marking included?
- Printing or accessories included?
- Taxes shown separately or inside the price?
- Currency stated?
Step 3: Align delivery terms
- Delivery place: your site or the supplier’s premises?
- Delivery terms named, for example using Incoterms
- Who pays freight, insurance and unloading?
- One shipment or staged?
- Lead time stated as a date or as a number of days from order?
For cross-border orders, importers need a commercial invoice, a detailed packing list and a certificate of origin, and sometimes an import permit. Ask each supplier which of these they provide and who handles customs clearance.
Step 4: Check documents and approvals
- Datasheets and certificates offered with the goods
- Samples available before the order, and their lead time
- Any document your project submission process requires
Step 5: Check commercial terms
- Payment terms and any advance requirement
- Validity of the quotation
- Cancellation and change terms
- Warranty or return terms, if any
Step 6: Compare on a table
A simple table does the work. List suppliers across the top and these rows down the side: specification match, unit price, total for the specified quantity, what is excluded, delivery date, delivery terms, documents, payment terms and validity. Fill each cell from the quotation text, and mark gaps for clarification.
Step 7: Clarify in writing
Send the same questions to every supplier. Keep replies in one thread so the record is clear. Avoid sharing one supplier’s price with another, since the aim is comparable offers, not a bidding exercise, unless your procurement policy says otherwise.
A worked comparison
Two quotations arrive for 200 pairs of safety shoes. Supplier A shows a lower unit price for a shoe, delivered to the buyer’s site, in one shipment, with a datasheet. Supplier B shows a higher unit price for an ankle boot, with a size split confirmed, and says the delivery date is confirmed. The lower price is not the better offer until the styles match. Ask supplier A to confirm style and sizes, then compare again. The example is made up to show why the first step is alignment.
Keeping a record
Keep one folder per RFQ: the request, each quotation, the clarifications and the final choice with the reason. A record protects your purchasing process and makes the next RFQ faster. If a supplier changes terms after the order, you have the original offer in hand.
A comparison table you can copy
| Row | Supplier A | Supplier B | Supplier C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Item and model offered | |||
| Matches the specification line by line (yes, no, equivalent) | |||
| Quantity and unit | |||
| Unit price and total, with currency | |||
| Included: packing, marking, printing, accessories | |||
| Excluded or optional items | |||
| Delivery place and terms | |||
| Lead time: confirmed date or estimate | |||
| Documents offered | |||
| Payment terms | |||
| Validity of the quotation | |||
| Open questions sent |
Fill each cell from the quotation text, and write “not stated” where a supplier is silent. A column full of “not stated” cells tells you what to ask next.
Three common situations
- One supplier is much cheaper. Check the item first. A different style, a smaller pack or a missing accessory explains most gaps. Ask the supplier to confirm the line against the specification in writing.
- Suppliers quote different delivery terms. Put them on the same basis before comparing totals. If one price is delivered to your site and another is at the supplier’s premises, add the transport and unloading you would have to arrange.
- An equivalent is offered. Ask for its datasheet, compare it with the specification and have the engineer or HSE officer approve it before you rank the offers.
Common mistakes
- Comparing totals before aligning units, so a price per box is set against a price per piece.
- Ranking on price when one offer has no stated validity.
- Sending different clarification questions to different suppliers, which makes the revised offers incomparable.
- Treating a lead time written as “ex stock” as a date. Ask for a date or a number of days from order.
- Losing the record. Keep the request, each quotation and the reasons for the choice in one place.
Red flags
- Quotation without validity date
- Totals that do not match the quantity
- Brands named with no model
- Delivery described as “ex stock” or “as soon as possible” without a date
- Different units between lines, such as boxes against pieces
Sending a clear RFQ
A good comparison starts with a good request. See how to write a PPE RFQ for the fields to include, or send your list to VMV Solutions LLC for a quotation.
What this guide does not do
It is a general buying checklist. It does not recommend any supplier, and it does not make any claim about our own products.
Ready to quote?
Send the item, specification, quantity and delivery location. Open the quote form with this topic filled in, or email sales@vmv-solutions.com.
Frequently asked questions
Should I always pick the lowest price?
Only after the quotations cover the same specification, quantity, delivery terms and documents. A lower total can leave out items or shift costs to you.
What if a supplier proposes an equivalent?
Ask for the datasheet of the equivalent and compare it with the specification line by line, then have your engineer or HSE officer approve it.
How long should a quotation be valid?
Long enough for your approval process, and state the validity you need in the RFQ.
Can I ask a supplier to revise a quotation?
Yes. Send the same clarification to every supplier so the revised offers stay comparable.
What do I do if lead times differ?
Compare on the delivery date you need and ask each supplier to state whether the date is confirmed or an estimate.
Sources
US International Trade Administration: UAE import requirements and documentation
